Deaf people prefer a Deaf therapist
In a poll of ~1,000 Deaf people, 85% chose a Deaf therapist.
Deaf people overwhelmingly prefer to work with a Deaf counselor. The McCullough and Duchesneau (2014) finding is similar to that of the Steinberg, A.G., Sullivan, V.J., & Loew, R.C. (1998) study, which found that out of 54 Deaf participants, 72% preferred a Deaf counselor and 15% preferred a hearing counselor.
McCullough, C.A., & Duchesneau, S.M. (2014, October 20).
Counselor preference [Web survey]. Retrieved from Survey Monkey (opens in a new tab)
This is DCC's own research with the Deaf community — one reason we are Deaf-owned and Deaf-run.
What other research shows
Published studies point the same way: shared language and shared experience make for a stronger relationship in therapy.
Shared experience and empathy
Researchers interviewed 16 Deaf trauma survivors. Some specifically preferred Deaf providers because they believed shared experiences would make it easier for the therapist to empathize. Participants emphasized direct signed communication and understanding Deaf history, and named the lack of Deaf role models as a barrier.
Why it matters: This study directly supports the value clients place on a therapist’s Deaf identity beyond signing ability alone.
Anderson, Wolf Craig & Ziedonis (2017), Psychological Trauma. Read the study (opens in a new tab)
Full reference
Anderson, M. L., Wolf Craig, K. S., & Ziedonis, D. M. (2017). Deaf people’s help-seeking following trauma: Experiences with and recommendations for the Massachusetts behavioral health care system. Psychological Trauma: Theory, Research, Practice, and Policy, 9(2), 239–248.
Stronger therapeutic relationship with direct communication
A doctoral study of 39 Deaf individuals found that people receiving therapy directly from a sign-fluent therapist reported stronger working alliance and attachment to their therapist than those receiving therapy through an interpreter.
Why it matters: This study supports an important feature of therapy offered by Deaf ASL-fluent clinicians: a direct relationship without an interpreter.
Spain (2017), Walden University. Read the study (opens in a new tab)
Full reference
Spain, S. L. (2017). Working alliance between interpretive and noninterpretive therapy services for Deaf individuals [Doctoral dissertation, Walden University].
Trust and belonging to the community
A qualitative study in Germany interviewed clients with hearing or vision impairments and the professionals who work with them. It identified distrust and therapists’ lack of membership in the client’s community as barriers. Findings included concerns that hearing therapists might not understand the experiences of clients with hearing loss, or might reproduce unequal power relationships.
Why it matters: This supports the rationale for offering therapists with shared lived experience.
Hardt and colleagues (2026), Psychology and Psychotherapy. Read the study (opens in a new tab)
Full reference
Hardt, B., Heidenreich, T., Hunger-Schoppe, C., Adam, N., Heinen, J., Hopf, J., Röhlig, A., & Michalak, J. (2026). Barriers and accessibility-improving strategies in mental health services for persons with hearing or vision impairments: Perspectives from professionals and clients. Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice, 99(1), 40–59.
Interpreted therapy requires additional coordination
A UK study of sign language interpreters working in mental health found that effective care depended on collaboration, continuity, and trust among the client, clinician, and interpreter. Participants also identified insufficient Deaf awareness among clinicians.
Why it matters: This provides an additional rationale for direct therapy with a licensed Deaf signing therapist, who removes the need to coordinate communication through a third person.
Chatzidamianos and colleagues (2019), Patient Education and Counseling. Read the study (opens in a new tab)
Full reference
Chatzidamianos, G., Fletcher, I., Wedlock, L., & Lever, R. (2019). Clinical communication and the “triangle of care” in mental health and deafness: Sign language interpreters’ perspectives. Patient Education and Counseling, 102(11), 2010–2015.
Talk to a Deaf therapist
Finding the right Deaf therapist can start with one message.
- Emailinfo@deafcounseling.cominfo@
deafcounseling.com - Text240 701 5155
- Videophone240 380 2577